Customer Reviews

4.74.7 out of 5 stars (based on 20 reviews)
Read Reviews

Betsy’s Best Cinnamon Peanut Butter

Betsy’s Best Cinnamon Peanut Butter — our original gourmet nut butter was created in Betsy Opyt’s home kitchen. Betsy, a registered dietitian, was on a mission to craft a super yummy and healthy all-natural peanut butter that her picky eating daughter would love. After blending up and trying many different spreads, her daughter finally loved one.


  • Delicious, wholesome ingredients
  • Delightful texture
  • Perfect for spreading, dipping, and everything in between

Featuring tasty superfood ingredients including cinnamon, Himalayan pink salt, organic honey, and crunchy chia seeds, our gourmet peanut butter is now loved by thousands of kids and adults around the United States. Dollop this healthy nut butter on celery sticks and apple slices, or treat yourself to a sophisticated PB&J. Regardless of how you try it, we bet you’ll soon be saying “It was love at first taste!” Order Betsy’s yummy non-GMO peanut butter today!


  • Net Weight: 16-oz.

More About Our Gourmet Cinnamon Peanut Butter

Kids Will Love It – Created by Betsy specifically for her daughter, Betsy’s Best Cinnamon Peanut Butter is a sweet healthy treat that even the pickiest kids will love.  While it has a sweet and salty taste, it is loaded with nutrition that all moms will like. Peanuts are packed with fiber, protein, essential nutrients and healthy fats. Plus, Betsy’s Best is enhanced with great tasting, nutrient dense superfoods including cinnamon, Himalayan pink salt and chia seeds.  Your kids will love our cinnamon peanut butter on its own, or in cookies and PB&Js.

Great in Recipes – Betsy’s Best Cinnamon Peanut Butter adds extra flavor and nutrition to all-kinds of recipes. Among our favorites are gourmet PB&J sandwiches. With ingredients like whole grain toast, blackberry or red pepper preserves, bacon or mint, you’ll be wondering why this classic sandwich was forgotten as an adult.  Our cinnamon peanut butter is also a huge flafor enhancer in smoothies, Thai peanut sauces, cookies, BBQ sauces, and more!  Add Betsy Best to your favorite recipes and we promise you’ll #TasteTheDifference!

A Sweet, Low Sugar Treat – Our Cinnamon Peanut Butter is 100% Natural, GMO-Free and has only 4 grams of all-natural sugar per serving. Using a unique blend of organic honey, Demerara sugar, and organic stevia leaf extract, Betsy, a registered dietitian, is able to offer a tantalizingly sweet treat that is healthy for your whole family. Many of our fans even substitute Betsy’s Best for those high-sugar hazelnut spreads and cookie butters!

Best Taste Guarantee — Betsy’s Best Cinnamon Peanut Butter is a unique and flavorful gourmet spread.  While we get rave reviews on Amazon and social media, we recognize that every person has their own taste preferences. That’s why we offer you an exclusive 60 Day Money Back Guarantee. If for any reason, you are not fully satisfied, please contact us for a replacement, substitute or full refund.

If you have any questions or comments, please contact us.

A Non-GMO Project Verified, Gluten-Free, Low Sugar Product

Cinnamon Peanut Butter Ingredients:

roasted peanuts, chia seeds, Demerara sugar, organic honey, cinnamon, sunflower oil, Himalayan pink salt, organic stevia leaf extract, natural flavors

Betsy’s Best Cinnamon Peanut Butter Reviews

Recent Reviews

Best peanut butter I’ve ever tasted

September 7, 2018

I just love Betsy’s Best peanut butter. The chia seeds give it a nice crunch and they are so healthy for you. I like to low sodium and sugar contents. I finally can eat peanut butter without guilt.

Charles Dunlap

Response from Betsy's Best

We are so glad to hear you love our peanut butter! Thank you!

Too Sweet But Good

August 31, 2018

I guess I am more of a plain natural peanut butter lover. This PB tastes good, but it is too sweet for me to use regularly. Maybe I’ll use it in a peanut butter cookie recipe.

Monika Patel

Response from Betsy's Best

Hi Monika – We are sorry to hear you think it is too sweet. Each serving has only 3g of sugar, so it is low in sugar. Our sweeteners are also 100% all natural. We get that some people just like a pure ground peanut spread. Hopefully you will enjoy it in the peanut butter cookies you plan to make. If you want, just request a refund via our contact us page. Our 100% satisfaction guarantee stands true!

Totally Addictive!

August 14, 2018

I have never loved nut/seed butters until I tried this! I have to admit I eat it straight out of the jar for a sweet treat- totally addictive in the best way. Delicious, high quality product that I don’t feel bad about eating 🙂 Love that it is has a little crunch/texture.

Cheryl Leahy

A little goes a long way

July 12, 2018

soooo good. i highly recommend. great with fruit.


Peanut Butter, Perfected

August 21, 2017

Before I tried Betsy’s Best, I would only eat peanut butter in cookies. I didn’t care for the taste, because it was plain. Betsy’s Best gourmet peanut butter, though? Cookies, yes. Also dipping sauce, marinade, and of course, SANDWICHES. I had my first peanut butter sandwich as a 33 year old woman, and it was divine. (I made it with Betsy’s Best peanut butter, and layered on some fresh mango slices plus a drizzle of honey.) The simple, healthy ingredients make it an easy choice–but the flavor makes it the ONLY choice for us.

Tayè Karunanithy


June 30, 2017

Like the Almond Butter, Betsy’s Best Peanut Butter is phenomenal. Can’t get enough of the neat texture that the salt, sugar, and chia seeds add. I eat this for breakfast; snacks; as a way to indulge in my treatsy tooth without going overboard in nutrition; etc. I would recommend this product to anyone who loves peanut butter. You will be hooked.


Perfect Peanut Butter

June 19, 2017

Great tasting peanut butter with smooth texture. This one is a huge hit in our family. Awesome product.


My New Fav

June 17, 2017

I love this peanut butter! My fiancé puts it on his toast, and I love it in smoothies or in muffins. It’s so smooth and creamy and has such great flavor. Goodbye to Jiff!


Healthier Peanut Butter

June 9, 2017

This peanut butter is an awesome alternative to your regular one. It’s extremely healthier and its non GMO. It’s great in your yogurt smoothies as well

Amber Stewart

My Go-To

May 25, 2017

This peanut butter is hands down my favorite! And I’ve tried more than a handful of different brands – the addiction is real 😉 The salty/ sweet flavors blend beautifully with the cinnamon and the crunchy chia seeds give each spoonful an added bonus bite! I have at least a spoonful every day, either on toast or drizzled over my morning bowl of greek yogurt and fruit. Simply delicious!


Write a Review

Get New Recipes

Print Friendly, PDF & Email